Federal plan comparison · updated October 7, 2026
IBR vs. RAP Monthly Payments: Which Would Cost Less?
Compare the Income-Based Repayment and Repayment Assistance Plan monthly-payment formulas, see worked examples, and check the loan and borrower rules that can change your result.
The short answer
RAP calculates a payment from an AGI band, then subtracts $50 per qualifying dependent claimed on your federal tax return, subject to a $10 minimum. IBR calculates 10% or 15% of discretionary income above 150% of the poverty guideline, with a cap tied to your 10-year Standard payment. Which costs less depends on your income, eligible loans, household details, IBR category, and qualifying-payment history.
Federal rules checked October 7, 2026. RAP rules took effect July 1, 2026. Confirm current account-specific eligibility and payment amounts with Federal Student Aid or your servicer.
- 34 CFR § 685.209 — Income-driven repayment plansU.S. Department of Education / eCFR · checked October 7, 2026
- 34 CFR § 682.215 — Income-based repayment plan for FFEL loansU.S. Department of Education / eCFR · checked October 7, 2026
- 34 CFR § 685.219 — Public Service Loan Forgiveness ProgramU.S. Department of Education / eCFR · checked October 7, 2026
- 34 CFR § 685.208 — Fixed payment repayment plans (IBR payment cap)U.S. Department of Education / eCFR · checked October 7, 2026
- 2026 HHS Poverty Guidelines (91 FR 1797)U.S. Department of Health and Human Services / Federal Register · checked October 7, 2026
- Income-Driven Repayment (IDR) PlansFederal Student Aid · checked October 7, 2026
IBR vs. RAP monthly payment examples
These formula-based examples make the monthly comparison concrete. They are not personalized estimates, eligibility decisions, or total-cost projections. On a small screen, scroll the table horizontally to view every column.
| Annual AGI | RAP formula 0 qualifying dependents | IBR formula before cap 10% category | IBR formula before cap 15% category |
|---|---|---|---|
| $40,000 | $100.00 / month | $133.83 / month | $200.75 / month |
| $60,000 | $250.00 / month | $300.50 / month | $450.75 / month |
| $100,000 | $750.00 / month | $633.83 / month | $950.75 / month |
- Shared assumptions: one borrower, single tax filer, AGI as shown, no spouse income or spouse-loan allocation, and eligible Direct Loans made before July 1, 2026. Loan-level eligibility and any IBR enrollment restriction still need confirmation.
- IBR: family size one and the 2026 HHS poverty guideline for the 48 contiguous states and D.C. ($15,960); the formula is 10% or 15% of income above 150% of that guideline, divided by 12. The table shows the income-based amount before the 10-year Standard cap. If that cap is lower, the actual IBR payment is lower.
- RAP: zero qualifying tax-return dependents, so the $50 monthly reduction does not apply; the $10 minimum is not triggered in these examples. Each qualifying dependent generally reduces the calculated payment by $50, down to the $10 minimum (except a final payment).
In these examples RAP is lower than the uncapped IBR formula at $40,000 and $60,000 AGI. At $100,000, the 10% IBR formula is lower than RAP, even before any lower Standard cap. Your actual result can differ because of the IBR cap, RAP dependents, family size, tax filing, loan balance, eligibility, and payment history. A smaller monthly bill does not by itself mean a lower total cost.
RAP vs. IBR at a glance
This comparison summarizes the current federal rules. The official payment and eligibility determination belongs to Federal Student Aid and your loan servicer.
| Decision factor | RAP | IBR |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly payment formula | Annual base amount: $120 when AGI is $10,000 or less; above $10,000, the applicable rate rises from 1% to 10% across $10,000 AGI bands. Divide by 12, then subtract $50 per qualifying dependent claimed on the federal return. The monthly minimum is $10, except for a final payment. | 10% of discretionary income for a new IBR borrower or 15% for other borrowers, divided by 12. Discretionary income is income above 150% of the applicable poverty guideline. Payment is capped at the 10-year Standard amount based on eligible balances and rates when IBR began. |
| Household information | Uses AGI and the number of qualifying dependents claimed on the federal tax return. If married filing jointly, spouse income and eligible loan debt may affect the calculation; regulatory exceptions apply in specified circumstances. | Uses AGI and federal family-size rules. Joint filing generally includes spouse income, with specified exceptions; eligible spouse loan balances can adjust the payment when spouse income is included. |
| Eligible loans and key limits | Eligible Direct Subsidized and Unsubsidized Loans, graduate/professional PLUS Loans, and eligible Direct Consolidation Loans. Parent PLUS and certain consolidations that repaid Parent PLUS are excluded. | Direct Loans made before July 1, 2026 may qualify under current Direct Loan rules. Parent PLUS and certain related consolidations are excluded. Some FFEL borrowers are subject to separate IBR rules; loan type and consolidation history matter. |
| Borrower category | No 10%/15% IBR borrower category; the published AGI-band formula applies. RAP eligibility still depends on eligible loan types and borrower/account details. | Under Direct Loan IBR, new borrowers generally use 10% and a 20-year qualifying-payment horizon; other borrowers generally use 15% and 25 years. Federal loan history determines the category. FFEL IBR has separate rules. |
| Unpaid-interest and principal treatment | Federal rules provide an interest benefit for on-time payments and a conditional matching principal payment when an on-time payment reduces principal by less than $50. Conditions apply. | Federal rules provide a limited interest benefit on eligible subsidized loans during the first three consecutive IBR repayment years; other unpaid interest is treated under the applicable rules. |
| Plan forgiveness | Remaining balance may be forgiven after 360 qualifying monthly payments (at least 30 years), subject to the detailed credit and plan requirements. | For Direct Loan IBR, 240 qualifying monthly payments (20 years) for new borrowers or 300 (25 years) for other borrowers. FFEL loans have separate rules, generally including a 25-year period. |
| PSLF | RAP is a qualifying repayment plan. Eligible Direct Loans, qualifying employment, and all other PSLF requirements still apply. | IBR is a qualifying repayment plan. Eligible Direct Loans, qualifying employment, and all other PSLF requirements still apply. |
A lower required payment is not automatically a lower total cost. Interest, balance changes, taxes, forgiveness eligibility, prior payment credits, and future income can change the result. RepayPilot does not forecast those outcomes here.
Eligibility checklist: what to verify before choosing
Use your StudentAid.gov loan details and servicer records. A plan name or a single loan-date answer is not enough to establish eligibility.
- Loan type and history: identify Direct, FFEL, graduate PLUS, Parent PLUS, and consolidation loans, including which loans each consolidation repaid.
- Disbursement dates: list each relevant Direct Loan date, especially any loan made on or after July 1, 2026. Current rules do not allow those Direct Loans to be repaid under IBR.
- IBR borrower category: check whether you meet the federal “new borrower” definition for the 10%/20-year category or fall under the 15%/25-year category.
- REPAYE payment history: the current Direct Loan IBR rule excludes enrollment for borrowers with 60 or more qualifying REPAYE repayments on or after July 1, 2024.
- Income and household facts: gather current AGI, tax filing status, RAP tax-return dependents, IBR family size, and spouse income/eligible loan details when applicable.
- Progress and goals: verify your current payment amount, credited qualifying months, upcoming recertification, PSLF employer/payment status, and any servicer transition notice.
Default status and special loan or transition circumstances can change which provisions apply. Ask Federal Student Aid or your servicer to confirm your exact loan-by-loan options before switching.
For the RAP-specific loan-type checklist, Parent PLUS exception, and facts needed for a personalized eligibility review, see Am I eligible for RAP?
Important dates under current federal rules
- July 1, 2026: RAP became available under current regulations. Direct Loans made on or after this date are not eligible for IBR under the Direct Loan rules.
- July 1, 2028: the current regulation sets a transition for borrowers repaying Direct Loans under PAYE or ICR and certain associated administrative forbearances. Eligible borrowers must select a replacement plan before the deadline; check your own Federal Student Aid and servicer notices.
These dates do not decide eligibility by themselves. Rules may change, and borrowers can have loans with different histories and options.
Borrower scenarios (illustrative, not payment estimates)
These examples state assumptions rather than inventing monthly amounts. Your loan record and official payment notice control.
Older Direct Loans, considering either plan
Assumptions: all loans in question were made before July 1, 2026, are eligible Direct Loans, and no IBR enrollment restriction applies. Compare RAP’s AGI-band/dependent formula with your IBR category, payment cap, and credited months; either plan may fit better.
A new Direct Loan made on or after July 1, 2026
Assumptions: the loan is a Direct Loan type eligible for RAP. That loan cannot be repaid under IBR under current rules, while RAP may be available. Do not assume older loans have identical eligibility or payment treatment; have the servicer review each loan.
Dependents and a larger IBR family size
Assumptions: the borrower claims qualifying dependents and also meets federal IBR family-size rules. RAP’s $50-per-dependent reduction and IBR’s poverty-guideline calculation use different household measures, so compare both with verified tax and family details.
A borrower pursuing PSLF
Assumptions: the borrower has eligible Direct Loans and works full time for a qualifying employer. Both RAP and IBR are qualifying repayment plans, but only months meeting the other PSLF rules count. Confirm the official count before changing plans.
Compare RAP and IBR using your numbers
Use RepayPilot’s free calculator for a side-by-side estimate based on the inputs it supports. It is educational decision support—not an eligibility decision, official payment quote, or forgiveness projection. Confirm results with your servicer.
For a separate, account-based analysis, see the optional $49 RepayPilot Report . It does not use your calculator entries.
RAP vs. IBR frequently asked questions
Is RAP better than IBR?
Neither plan is best for every borrower. RAP and IBR use different income formulas, family measures, eligibility rules, and forgiveness timelines. The right comparison depends on your eligible loans, adjusted gross income, household and tax details, IBR borrower category, qualifying-payment history, and PSLF goals.
Which plan has the lower RAP vs. IBR monthly payment?
There is no universal lower-payment plan. RAP uses an AGI-band base amount, a $50 monthly reduction per qualifying dependent, and a $10 minimum (except a final payment). IBR uses 10% or 15% of discretionary income above 150% of the applicable poverty guideline, subject to a 10-year Standard-payment cap. Use current information and ask your servicer to confirm the official amounts.
What are example RAP vs. IBR monthly payments?
For a single borrower with $40,000 AGI, family size one, no RAP dependents, and the 2026 contiguous-states poverty guideline, the RAP formula is $100 per month. The IBR formula before its Standard-payment cap is $133.83 for the 10% category or $200.75 for the 15% category. These are illustrations, not quotes: a lower IBR cap or RAP dependent reduction can change the comparison, and eligibility must be confirmed.
Can IBR still be available if I received a loan on or after July 1, 2026?
Under the current Direct Loan rules, only Direct Loans made before July 1, 2026 may be repaid under IBR. That post-cutoff loan is not IBR-eligible. Whether other older loans remain eligible depends on your loan history and applicable rules; verify your account with Federal Student Aid or your servicer.
What happens to borrowers on PAYE or ICR by July 1, 2028?
The current federal regulation sets a July 1, 2028 transition for borrowers repaying Direct Loans under PAYE or ICR and certain associated administrative forbearances. Your available replacement plans depend on loan-level eligibility. Follow your Federal Student Aid and servicer notices and confirm your options before the deadline.
How do dependents and family size affect RAP vs. IBR?
RAP subtracts $50 per month for each qualifying dependent claimed on the borrower’s federal tax return. IBR uses federal family-size rules when applying the 150%-of-poverty threshold; family size is not simply the number of dependents claimed for RAP. Income and spouse treatment also depend on filing status and the circumstances allowed by the rules.
Do RAP and IBR payments count toward PSLF?
RAP and IBR are qualifying repayment plans for PSLF. A qualifying plan alone is not enough: the borrower must also have eligible Direct Loans, qualifying full-time employment, and qualifying payments, among other program requirements. Check your official PSLF payment count and employment certification.
Does the 20-, 25-, or 30-year forgiveness period guarantee forgiveness by that date?
No. The periods refer to qualifying monthly payments (or equivalents) and include detailed rules for which months count. Prior payment credit, eligible loan history, plan changes, and other circumstances can affect your remaining timeline. Confirm your payment history and forgiveness progress with your servicer or Federal Student Aid.
Is the optional RepayPilot Report required to apply for RAP or IBR?
No. Federal Student Aid and loan servicers provide federal repayment-plan information and application channels for free. The RepayPilot Report is a separate, optional $49 one-time product; it is not an application and is not required to receive federal assistance.
Federal sources and verification
Rules checked October 7, 2026. The regulations can change; check the live federal sources and your own account before acting.
- 34 CFR § 685.209 — Income-driven repayment plansU.S. Department of Education / eCFR · checked October 7, 2026
- 34 CFR § 682.215 — Income-based repayment plan for FFEL loansU.S. Department of Education / eCFR · checked October 7, 2026
- 34 CFR § 685.219 — Public Service Loan Forgiveness ProgramU.S. Department of Education / eCFR · checked October 7, 2026
- 34 CFR § 685.208 — Fixed payment repayment plans (IBR payment cap)U.S. Department of Education / eCFR · checked October 7, 2026
- 2026 HHS Poverty Guidelines (91 FR 1797)U.S. Department of Health and Human Services / Federal Register · checked October 7, 2026
- Income-Driven Repayment (IDR) PlansFederal Student Aid · checked October 7, 2026